WE HAVE KNOWLEDGE

Experience Real New York Pizza in North Carolina

When you crave real New York pizza, you know the experience should be unforgettable. Our team at Tony’s Pizza brings authentic NY pizza to North Carolina, capturing the taste you remember from the Big Apple. Each bite offers a crisp, chewy crust, a sauce with balanced sweetness and acidity, and gooey mozzarella cheese. We invite you to enjoy our pies by dining in, picking up, or ordering delivery. At Tony’s Pizza, we are proud to share our passion for New York style pizza with every customer.

What Makes New York Style Pizza Unique?

Many people ask what sets New York style pizza apart from other pizzerias. The answer lies in tradition and detail. New York pizza originated in the city and quickly became a symbol of quality and flavor. As pizza spread across the country, different regions developed their own styles, but NY pizza kept its unique character.

Key features of New York style pizza:

• Large, foldable slices and pies
• Thin, crispy, yet chewy crust
• Simple, fresh tomato sauce with the right balance of sweet and tart
• Low-moisture mozzarella that melts perfectly

These details make our pizza New York style and set us apart from the rest.

How We Create Real New York Pizza

Some pizzerias claim to offer New York style pizza, but not all live up to the name. At Tony’s Pizza, we stay true to our roots by using the same techniques and recipes that started it all.

Top-Quality Ingredients

We believe every great dish starts with the best ingredients. Our tomatoes, cheese, and vegetables are always fresh. This ensures our sauce bursts with flavor and our toppings taste vibrant. We use specialty tomatoes, salt, and special spices in our pizza sauce.

Traditional Dough Preparation

Our dough is made with precision and care. We prepare it to develop flavor and the perfect consistency. Next, our skilled pizza makers hand-toss every crust. This process gives our pies the signature texture you expect from real NY pizza.

Proper Cooking Methods

We cook our pizzas on the deck of a high-temperature oven. This technique delivers a slightly charred, flavorful crust that can’t be matched by conveyor ovens. The end result is a pizza that tastes just like it does in New York.

Avoiding Common Pizza Mistakes

We see many pizzerias try to imitate NY pizza, but they often fall short. At Tony’s Pizza, we avoid these mistakes:

• Using anything less than fresh, high-quality ingredients
• Rushing dough or skipping fermentation
• Cooking pizzas in conveyor ovens

By staying true to our New York pizza recipe, we ensure every slice meets your expectations.

Our Menu Offers More Than Real New York Pizza

While pizza is our specialty, our menu is packed with Italian favorites. You’ll find something for everyone at Tony’s Pizza.

Some of our menu highlights include:

• Appetizers, like garlic knots and wings
• Pasta dishes, such as lasagna, ravioli, and baked ziti
• Parmigiana options with chicken or eggplant
• Calzones and strombolis
• Crisp salads and savory subs
• Homemade desserts

We also offer specialty crusts, including cauliflower and rice, for those with dietary needs. Please note, our kitchen is not gluten-free, so cross-contamination is possible.

Our History and Locations

Our story began in 1981, when three Italian brothers left Brooklyn, NY, to bring real New York pizza to North Carolina. We opened our first pizzerias in Jacksonville and Havelock, and now we have six locations in the Charlotte and Hickory areas. Our sister restaurant, Mario’s, offers more NY style pizza at nine locations in the Piedmont Triad.

Our team stays true to our founding values:

• Using fresh, top-quality ingredients
• Honoring traditional cooking methods
• Providing friendly, attentive service
• Keeping our menu affordable for families

Pizza Sizes and Toppings Galore

We know everyone has a favorite pizza size and topping combination. At Tony’s Pizza, you can choose from several pie sizes:

• 12 inches
• 15 inches
• 17 inches
• 19 inches
• 24 inches

We offer 32 different toppings, so you can build your perfect pizza. Whether you love classics like pepperoni and mushrooms or want something unique like artichoke hearts or feta, we have you covered. Our specialty pizzas, such as the Greenhouse, 5 Boroughs, and Margherita, combine flavors to delight every palate.

Frequently Asked Questions About Tony’s Pizza

We know you may have questions before your first visit. Below, our team answers some of the most common questions about our pizzerias and our New York style pizza.

Where can I find authentic pizza New York style in North Carolina?

You can visit Tony’s Pizza at any of our six locations in Charlotte and Hickory. Our sister restaurant, Mario’s, has nine more locations in the Piedmont Triad. We follow the same recipes and traditions that made us famous.

Why Choose Tony’s for Real NY Pizza?

Great pizza is about more than just ingredients—it’s about tradition and care. We bring decades of experience and a deep love for real New York pizza to every pie we make. Our recipes come straight from our family’s kitchen in Brooklyn. We invite you to taste the difference for yourself.

What makes Tony’s the best New York style pizza?

Ultimately, we think our customers know best! Here’s what a few of them say:

Eddie Z here again.if you like New York, New Jersey pizza,you’ll love Tony’s. This is the crown jewel of pizza shops anywhere in the state and we have been to many. Delicious dough,crispy bottom,good sauce and cheese make this a one of a kind pie. Visited Long Island recently and went to my old pizza joint and Tony’s was as good as the Long Island one.  – Ed Z.

I was born, bred, and spent the first 47 yrs of my life in NYC. I’d put Tony’s pizza up against the best NY (traditional pie) has to offer. Added bonus — the staff is always enthusiastic and friendly. – Mike G.

If you’re in Mooresville, NC, and craving authentic New York-style pizza, look no further than Tony’s Pizza. During our two-week stay at a house on the lake, we tried their classic cheese pie–and it was so good, we went back for more!

The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, the cheese had that salty, gooey deliciousness you dream of, and the sauce was just the right balance of tangy and sweet. This place nails it.

Highly recommend stopping by if you’re in the area–this is legit New York-style pizza at its best! – Stephanie L.

Do you offer gluten-free or special crusts?

We provide cauliflower and rice crust options. However, our kitchen is not gluten-free, so cross-contamination is possible.

Who has the best pizza in town?

At Tony’s Pizza, we believe life is too short for anything but the best pizza. Try us for authentic NY flavor, friendly service, and a menu full of Italian classics. Before you come to find out where the best real New York pizza is, be sure to follow us on Facebook for the latest deals and news. We look forward to seeing you!