Gift of Flavor!
Gift cards are available in any amount in any restaurant or on our app
We impose a surcharge of 3.5% on the transaction amount on credit card products, which is not greater than our cost of acceptance. We do not surcharge debit cards, prepaid cards or gift cards. Prices are subject to change without notice.
View menu and more
In the Triad area? Visit our sister restaurant, Mario's Pizza!
and we love to share!
We get it. Authentic New York style pizza is sometimes hard to find. We also understand that when you want it, you want it done right. After all, most people (especially New Yorkers) are very passionate about crispy, yet chewy, Brooklyn style pizza that gives them a taste of home. Thus, if you’re searching online for New York style pizza near me, our team at Tony’s Pizza is here to help!
After all, our owners originally made our NY style pizza in…New York! From there, we brought our family recipes down to North Carolina to share that taste of home throughout Charlotte, Hickory and even the Piedmont (at our sister store, Mario’s Pizza).
Generally, when folks are talking about pizza styles, they typically think of two main types – NY-Style Pizza and Chicago-Style Pizza. In reality, there are lots of other types out there but these tend to be the two that most pizzerias attempt to master.
However, master is the keyword. Especially, this is true with the New York Style pizza near me that you’re searching for in the NC area. Just because someone decides to make it, doesn’t mean they know how to make it best. With a thin and chewy yet crispy crust, this masterpiece requires some special ingredients and special handling.
Notably, hand-tossing this crust is key. This method evenly spreads out the dough into it’s iconic thin layer. Then, chefs place specially blended tomato sauce, low-moisture cheese and other tasty toppings on top.
Conversely, Chicago-style pizza, aka deep dish, has a much thicker crust. It’s sauce and toppings are chunkier and layered. Many folks pull out a fork to eat it as opposed to folding it like you can do with a NY-style slice. In fact, that probably wouldn’t end too well.
Since you’re searching for New York style pizza near me, we’re going to assume we’re in like company and be honest. We get that other folks like other styles but we think NY-Style is hands down the best. If you’re wondering why, here’s what we think.
First, a lot of folks think it’s superior because of the water in New York. However, we feel it is more related to the recipe. Through the generations and continents, we passed our recipes down all the way from Italy to New York. First, we opened a pizzeria in Brooklyn. Then, we headed to the North Carolina coast for a bit. Finally, we settled in the Charlotte area and the Triad where we definitively discovered that you don’t have to have New York water to make authentic NY-style pizza.
Plus, we use the traditional cooking methods of specially-made ovens that give our crust that chewy crispness our customers crave.
Of course, we love pizza. Although, if you’d like to enjoy the palette of a New Yorker a bit, there are some other great foods to try as well. You can find variations throughout Charlotte and the Triad including some at Tony’s and Mario’s Pizza!
In fact, we have lots of other delightful dishes including meatballs, fried ravioli, wings, stromboli, calzone, lasagna…check out our menu for a full mouth-watering list!
If you haven’t tried our fare yet, you may have some questions. Here are a few our customers ask most frequently.
Yes! We currently offer delivery through several major food deliver apps, including DoorDash. Similarly, you can order ahead for pickup through our app, website or via phone.
As we mentioned, our Italian restaurant offers a wide range of options including Italian dishes, salads, subs, and tons of great sides and appetizers. You can order pizza by the slice as well in case your party can’t agree on toppings or if everyone wants something different.
Absolutely! Just download our app or use your phone number to sign-up in person when you order. As a member, you earn points for every order, as well as birthday rewards and other offers.
We have multiple restaurants throughout Charlotte and one in Hickory:
In Huntersville, you’ll find us at:
If in Mooresville, you’ll find Tony’s Pizza at:
If you’re in Charlotte we’re located on:
In Hickory we are at:
Additionally, if you’re visiting the Greensboro or Winston area, New York style pizza near me is still easy to find. We have three family-owned locations in Winston-Salem, two locations in High Point, one location in Clemmons, and three locations in Greensboro, including our new restaurant at Friendly Center.