WE HAVE KNOWLEDGE

Savor a NY Pizza Slice in North Carolina

When you think of Southern cuisine, barbecue or fried chicken might come to mind. But at Tony’s Pizza, we bring the classic NY pizza slice to Charlotte and Hickory. Our family-owned pizzeria serves up authentic Italian flavors, allowing you to enjoy a true slice of New York right here in North Carolina.

How the Famous NY Pizza Slice Journeyed to America

Our story starts in Naples, Italy, where pizza a portafoglio — folded like a wallet — became a favorite for the working class. This portable meal was affordable and easy to eat while on the move. As Italians journeyed to America, they brought their pizza traditions with them. Here, coal-fired ovens replaced the wood-fired ones from Italy. These ovens created a crispier, drier crust, making the pizza perfect for whole pies.

With the introduction of gas ovens, our pizza options expanded. Gas ovens bake pies at a different pace, making it possible to reheat slices without sacrificing texture. This innovation allowed New York shops to sell pizza by the slice. Large ovens also meant bigger pies, and folding those wide slices kept all the delicious toppings in place. That’s how the NY pizza slice became an iconic street food in America.

What Sets NY Pizza Apart

Our customers often ask why NY style pizza stands out from the crowd. The answer starts with the crust. Here’s how we achieve that signature NY pizza slice:

• We use high-protein flour for strength and chewiness.
• Our dough is perfectly hydrated and slowly fermented.
• Every crust is hand-tossed by our skilled team members.
• We bake each pizza using classic methods for the ideal crispness.

Our tomato sauce is simple, letting the natural flavors shine. We top each pie with low-moisture mozzarella, which melts beautifully and keeps the crust from getting soggy. All these elements combine to create a pizza that’s both crispy and chewy, with a balance of savory flavors in every bite.

Our Family’s Pizza Tradition

Pizza making runs deep in our family. Our roots trace back to Calabria, Italy, and our journey brought us from Brooklyn to North Carolina in 1981. Since then, Tony, Vinny, and Mario have dedicated themselves to sharing authentic Italian recipes with the South.

We stick to the traditions that make our pizza memorable:
• Fresh, quality ingredients star in every dish.
• Hand tossing ensures the right texture for our dough.
• Every step honors traditional techniques passed down through generations.
• Our recipes come straight from our family’s kitchen in Calabria.
• We offer 32 topping choices, so everyone can create their perfect pie.

Why Our NY Pizza Slice Is So Popular

Our guests love the versatility of our menu and the care we put into every pizza. At Tony’s, we never cut corners. We make each NY pizza slice with pride, using only the best ingredients. The result is a delicious, satisfying meal whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch or enjoying a family dinner.

We also believe pizza brings people together. That’s why our restaurants are warm, welcoming spaces. Our team members greet everyone like family, whether you’re a regular or a first-time visitor. We want you to feel at home while enjoying an authentic NY pizza slice.

More Than Just Pizza

While our NY pizza slice is a customer favorite, our menu has something for everyone. We serve classic Italian dishes like lasagna and ravioli, hearty subs, fresh salads, and tempting desserts. Whether you’re dining in or ordering for pickup or delivery, you’ll find a meal to satisfy any craving at Tony’s Pizza.

Ordering Is Simple and Convenient

We know life is busy, so we make ordering easy. Our website and app let you choose what you want, when you want it. Pick your favorite NY pizza slice, select your toppings, and decide if you want pickup or delivery. We’ll prepare your meal with care and get it to you fast.

Loyalty Rewards for Pizza Lovers

At Tony’s Pizza, we appreciate our loyal customers. That’s why we have a rewards program designed just for you:

• Earn 1 point for every $2 spent.
• Redeem 50 points for a $5 credit.
• Enjoy a free pizza slice when you join.
• Receive a special birthday surprise.
• Get exclusive deals and insider offers.

Simply download our app or let a team member know you want to join. It’s our way of saying thank you for choosing us.

FAQs About Some of the Best Pizza in Town

Our team at Tony’s Pizza loves helping customers. We’ve answered some common questions below to help you get the most out of your experience.

Do you have a loyalty program?

Yes! Download our app (iPhone or android) or ask your server to join. Start earning points for every purchase and enjoy member perks.

Can I order pizza slices online?

Absolutely! Order through our website or app for easy pickup or delivery.

What other menu options do you offer?

Our menu includes Italian classics like pasta, subs, salads, and desserts. There’s something for everyone.

Where can I find Tony’s Pizza?

You’ll find our restaurants serving authentic NY pizza slices in Charlotte, Hickory, and other nearby locations.

5-Star Customer Reviews

If you still have some questions about the best NY style pizza near you, consider a few words from the experts – our customers! Below, we’ve listed a few of their kind words.

NY style pizza, the sauce is amazing, perfect robust and sweet mixture and the cheese is great. There are no pools of grease, you could eat a slice and not have to use a napkin. The pizza is paper thin, perfect amount of crust that is crispy and chewy. I order a plain cheese slice and its always perfect. The staff is always funny too, they seem to have a good time while doing their job! – Jib O.

This is true NY a style pizza! Crunch crunch crunchy crust and good flavor! I am an avid pizza eater, all over the US and abroad and this one made me smile. – Jason B.

Stopped in for 2 quick slices – they were HUGE, delicious, and super affordable! Really impressed, seem to have a great menu too, definitely will be trying more items, but their slices are fantastic. Great friendly staff, will be back in soon! – Jeff T.