Close on the tails of burgers, pizza is one of the second most popular fast foods in America. With a crispy crust, tangy sauce, and melty cheese, the flavorful favorite is tough to resist. Although, with so many pizzerias to choose from, how do you pick the best pizza Huntersville offers?

Must-Haves For A Great Pizza Place

There may be plentiful pizzerias in your town. However, not all have the best pizza Huntersville offers. Furthermore, the style of pizza is as important as the toppings. Whether you’re craving a big slice of  NY-style pizza or a deep dip into Chicago style, popular Italian restaurants have similar must-haves:

1. Fantastic Customer Reviews

First, search for reviews from customers.  At Tony’s Pizza, our loyal fan base loves to tell others about our pizza:

“Definitely service with a smile, Employees and food were outstanding. Pizza and wings were the best I’ve had in a good while. Definitely going to be coming back when I get the chance.” – Tony Church 

“Best Pizza in Huntersville. The Decor is tight also all NYC stuff! Been there, 300 times at least! Will be back! It changed owner’s, while I was still in NC! Pizza didn’t change! Yum.”– Michael Hartman

2. Multiple Menu Options

Of course, our specialty is delicious NY-Style pizza. Likewise, we offer many other delicious Italian dishes, appetizers, salads and desserts including: subs, calzones, stromboli, and parmigiana, meatballs, wings, cannoli, cheesecake and limoncello mascarpone cake.

3. Fabulous Food at Affordable Prices

Mostly, excellent Italian fare begins with traditional recipes from the old country. Tony’s Pizza traces their roots to Calabria, Italy.

Similarly, we also understand the importance of value and taking your family out to eat. Thus, we offer a kid’s menu with options for $5 and under along with daily specials for adults.

4. Ordering Online

Let’s face it, we all tend to lead busy lives. Ordering online is convenient. Therefore, Tony’s offers online ordering at all our locations. Choose to pick up your meal or have it delivered to your door. Whichever you choose, you’ll save time and get some great tasting pizza!

6 Qualities for the Best Tasting Pizza

While these pizzeria must-haves are important, let’s dig deeper into the best pizza Huntersville offers. After all, what really makes one restaurant’s pizza better than another? Below, here’s what we think makes the best tasting pizza.

1. Freshest Ingredients

Notably, fresh and preserved ingredients taste differently. When processed, these ingredients contain sodium, sugar, and preservatives to increase food’s shelf life. Unfortunately, these additives mar the true flavor. At Tony’s, we use the freshest ingredients possible.

2. Perfect Pizza Crust

Soggy, tasteless crust ruins any good pizza even if the toppings are superior. Whether you like thick or thin, best pizzas begin with well-crafted crust. Three characteristics that make the perfect crust are:

  • Texture
  • Thickness
  • Flavor

Hand tossing it a bit doesn’t hurt either. Another art we’ve perfected at Tony’s Pizza!

3. Savory Sauce

Once you perfect the base of your pizza, sauce is the next critical element. Perfectly seasoned fresh tomatoes enhance the overall flavor of the pie.

4. Tasty Toppings

True pizza lovers hotly debate which pizza toppings are best. Whichever combination you prefer, top pizza places offer plenty of options. At Tony’s Pizza, we have over twenty toppings to customize the perfect pizza.

5. Perfectly Cooked

Another hotly debated topic: wood-fired or gas oven? Each method may impart a slightly different taste. Although, seasoned chefs pay attention to oven temperature and cooking time as well.

6. Delicious

In the end, when you combine these qualities, you get a pizza that tastes delicious!

Best Pizza Huntersville – FAQs

Below, we’ve answered a few of our most commonly asked questions.

Do You Have Gluten-Free Pizza?

Absolutely! Choose from our rice-based or cauliflower crusts. Similarly, we have many gluten-free toppings. When you place your order, ask your server about safe options.

Do You Offer Special Deals?

Indeed, we do! Locate our daily specials on the menu section of our website. Better yet, join our loyalty program. Simply download the app from our website. Or, the next time you place an order, let a team member know you want to join.

Earn 1 point for every $2 you spend. Then, enjoy rewards for doing what you love – eating pizza! Get free food, $5 certificates, and special offers.

Where Can I Find Tony’s Pizza?

In Huntersville, you’ll find us at:

  • 9548 Mt. Holly-Huntersville RD

If in Mooresville, you’ll find Tony’s Pizza at:

  • 688 Bluefield Rd

We also have a location in Hickory:

  • 1832 Catawba Valley Blvd SE

If you’re in Charlotte we’re located on:

  • 1530 Overland Park Ln
  • 1605 Galleria Blvd
  • 14027 Conlan Circle

We look forward to proving that we have some of the best pizza Huntersville offers!

One thing that’s so great about North Carolina is that it’s a melting pot of folks from other states. Notably, this is especially true in the Charlotte, Huntersville and Mooresville area. Other than being a beautiful place to live, our mild climate coupled with affordability and economic opportunities draw an eclectic group of folks. Moreover, a large number of people in  North Carolina come from New York. Many of these folks still crave food from their hometowns. If you’re searching for the best pizza Mooresville restaurants have to offer, head over to Tony’s Pizza.

What Makes New York-Style Pizza Special?

Those who aren’t familiar with NY-style pizza, often wonder what makes it so special. After all, there are lots of other types of pizza such as Neapolitan or Chicago.

However, New York-Style Pizza is in a class of its own starting with the crust. We create the dough with a high-gluten flour mixed with water, salt, yeast, and olive oil. Then, we hand-toss it to form a crust that’s slightly thicker around the edges (this is a very crucial step!). Next, our chefs top the dough with seasoned tomato sauce. Typically, ingredients include garlic, basil, and oregano.

Atop our flavorful sauce, the chef sprinkles grated mozzarella cheese. Keep in mind, this mozzarella must be low moisture which gives pizza its stringy characteristic.

Finally, you get to customize your pie with all the delicious toppings we have to choose from. Often, our guests debate about which ingredients make the best pizza. At Tony’s Pizza, we have over 2 dozen delicious toppings to sate everyone’s taste buds.

Once baked, this hand-tossed crust is crispy, yet still foldable so you can eat it on the go.

Top Reasons Americans Adore Pizza

It’s practically a fact, pizza is one of America’s favorite foods. At least once a week, an estimated 40 percent of the population eats it. Here are a few reasons why we love this Italian dish:

  1. It’s Portable!

Initially, chefs cooked pizza in coal-fired ovens. Because it was cooked by this method, you could only buy pizza by the pie. Once gas-fueled ovens hit the scene in the 1930s, chefs could pre-bake pizza making slices easy to reheat. Thus, in New York City, all the residents traveling on foot could simply grab a slice of pizza and go.

Nowadays, most pizzerias still sell by the slice. Moreover, as we mentioned earlier, NY-style pizza easily folds still allowing diners to eat as they travel.

  1. Custom Designed

Whether you love veggies or meats, you’ll find plenty of awesome toppings to suit your taste buds. From trendy to traditional, mixing different toppings gives your pizza a whole new flavor.

  1. Fits the Food Groups

Some people view pizza as junk food. However, it has a combination of protein, carbs and fat which offers a nutritious balance. If you add fresh vegetable toppings, you get a boost of vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants. So, stop feeling guilty and eat up!

  1. Pizza Makes You Feel Good

When you eat pizza, your brain releases endorphins. These chemicals boost feelings of happiness. In a sense, eating pizza makes you feel good.

  1. It is Truly Delicious

Tangy tomato sauce, crispy crust and stringy cheese. Need we say more?

The Tony’s Difference

With so many other pizza restaurants in the Charlotte, Mooresville and Huntersville area, what makes Tony’s different?

First, brothers Mario, Tony, and Vinny grew up in a large Italian family in Brooklyn, NY. This family cooked and shared their ideas. Many of their recipes date back to their origins in Calabria, Italy.

Plus, we don’t want you to go away hungry. That’s why we make our pizza slices huge. In fact, they’re often much bigger than many other pizzerias in Mooresville and the Charlotte area.

Some of our customers think we make the best pizza in town. Here’s what a few of them have to say on TripAdvisor about us:

Eddie Z here again. Stopped for lunch after 14 months of not eating out and nothing had changed. Still the best pizza in the state and the closest to New York/New Jersey pizza you’ll find here. This is the real deal in pizza!”

“My family loves Tony’s Pizza. A large pizza takes up the entire table. Yes that is correct. We just ate from the pizza pan. There were two adults and two teenagers and we took 1/2 of the pizza home. Great sauce that makes my mouth water thinking about it. You will love Tony’s Pizza.”

“If you are looking for a true New York Style thin Pizza that is absolutely Yummy, it’s Tony’s Pizza! Eat it fresh and hot and you will be amazed. They also have a ton of other things on their menu, but I have to get pizza every time because it’s just that good! We did have wings with it on our last visit and they were very good as well.

FAQs About Best Pizza Mooresville Restaurants

The Charlotte area offers many great dining experiences including the best pizza Mooresville restaurants have to offer. Often, that makes it tough to choose where to eat. So you can get to know us better, here are answers to a few commonly asked questions.

Do You Have Other Menu Items?

In addition to pizza, we serve salads, calzones, Stromboli, subs and authentic Italian dishes. Likewise, we have tasty appetizers such as garlic knots, wings, and toasted ravioli. Better yet, order one of our sweet desserts as a delicious finale to your meal!

For our youngest diners, we offer a kid’s menu with smaller-sized portions. Kids love their dinner; parents appreciate the price. Each kid’s menu item is $5 or less.

Can I Get Home Delivery?

Absolutely! We offer delivery via Slice, Uber Eats, and DoorDash.

Where Can I Find The Nearest Tony’s Pizza?

We have several convenient locations throughout the Mooresville, Huntersville, Charlotte and Hickory area. Plus, you’ll find our delicious dishes at our sister store, Mario’s Pizza.

Wondering what to have for dinner tonight? Order one of our delicious meals now! When looking for one of the best pizza Mooresville restaurants, choose Tony’s Pizza.

Let’s face it, people’s lives are busy. Therefore, take out is often a necessity. From working, running errands, and getting the kids to their activities, there’s rarely time left to cook. Luckily, Tony’s Pizza can do it for you!  Likewise, when you’re busy, you need more than just quick food. It’s crucial that ordering is easy too. When searching for pizza places near me with easy online ordering and delicious food, pick Tony’s Pizza.

Ordering Online And Via Apps

Our busy lives demand convenience. Restaurant apps and online options make acquiring a hot meal for the family easier than ever. Just a little bit before mealtime, place an order, pick it up and consider dinner done! Or, pick a delivery service to bring your dinner right to your doorstep. Plus, everyone can order what they want rather than everyone having to select the same thing. Not only does this save time, everyone is happy with their delicious and personalized meal.

When you order out, you have tons of options. From burgers to chicken and Chinese to Latino, there is a lot to choose from. Unsurprisingly, pizza is one of America’s favorite choices. In fact, pizza is the food that most Americans would wish to eat for the rest of their lives. We totally get that!

Clearly, a quick internet search for pizza places near me proves that plentiful pizzerias exist. However, when you’re craving authentic New York-style pizza, Tony’s Pizza is your best option.

Pizza Places Near Me- New York Style

In 1905, Gennaro Lombardi introduced Americans to pizza. In the Little Italy neighborhood of Manhattan, he opened the countries first pizzeria. It quickly became a phenomenon and is akin to the NY-Style pizza we crave and adore today.

When Italians migrated to different parts of the country, these New York-style pizzerias migrated with them. In 1981, brothers Vinny, Tony, and Mario left Brooklyn and moved to the North Carolina coast where they opened a pizzeria in Jacksonville and Havelock.

Today, you can find Tony’s Pizza in Charlotte, Mooresville, Hickory, and Huntersville. Our restaurants are conveniently located to also serve the surrounding towns of Matthews, Lake Norman, Pineville, and Fort Mills. Plus, we offer convenient ordering from your smartphone or computer.

Fantastic Pizza And Italian Cuisine

Tony’s serves up several kinds of delightful pizzas New York style. Choose from 5 sizes – our 10” to our humungous 24”. Additionally, we have over 30 delicious toppings. Similarly, if you’d rather let us plan the toppings, pick one of our specialty pizzas. We even have a gluten-free option and vegan cheese for customers with special dietary needs.

Conversely, you may be in the mood for a calzone, stromboli, or sub. No worries! We’ve got that too! Furthermore, if you’d like something lighter, we also serve salads.

For kids, we have a menu for junior appetites. Our smaller portions are just the right size for little people.

Get Big Rewards with Our Loyalty Program

If you’ve already discovered our food, then you’ll enjoy our rewards program. For every in-store or online purchase, you earn 1 point for $2 spent. Once you reach 50 points, you get a $5 certificate towards your next purchase.

It’s easy to join and you receive a gift just for signing up! Download our app from the Google Play store or sign-up online. Or, ask one of our associates to sign you up the next time you visit.

Plus, we offer bonus points days and opportunities to earn extra rewards by signing up for our newsletter. Follow us on Facebook and Instagram for news on upcoming specials.

FAQs About The Best Pizza Places Near Me

Not surprisingly, you’ll find twenty plus pizzerias just in Charlotte alone. Thus, finding the best pizza places near me can be challenging. To help us stand out from the rest, we’ve answered a few of our most commonly asked questions.

What Makes New York-Style Pizza Special?

Often, New York-style pizza offered outside of New York city isn’t quite the same. Truly, you need someone who knows how to properly work the dough. That’s one of several tricks to creating authentic-style pizza. Similarly, you must you use high-quality ingredients. And…we add a little of our own magic as well!

Being Italian Brooklyn boys, our owners Vinny, Mario and Tony are well-versed in pizza dough tossing. Our pies are thick and crispy along the edge, yet soft enough to fold in half to eat.

Are Your Recipes Authentically Italian?

The history of Brooklyn, NY includes a huge influx of Italian immigrants who settled and made this area their home. These immigrants brought with them their family recipes from the old country.

Vinny, Tony, and Mario grew up among this large Italian population. Their meals included dishes made from family recipes from Calabria, Italy. Today, the brothers serve many of these same meals at their restaurants. You can’t get any more Italian than that.

Do You Handle Catering Orders?

Absolutely! You can order many of our delicious meals for your next event or party. Whether you’re in the mood for pizza, calzones, pasta or strombolis, we can help make your get-together memorable. Better yet, you can order several of our appetizers or desserts to complete your meal. (Please call us at least 72 hours before your event to allow us time to prepare your order.)

What Makes Tony’s Pizza Special?

Of course, we think our pizza is delicious. However, others think so too. Check out our rave reviews from customers around the NC area.

Here’s one of our favorites from T Brazz:

One of the best pizza spots in Charlotte. I made the mistake of not taking a picture of the pizza in the box, lol. We got a 24′ inch…had to put the box in the back seat, lol. I’m originally from NY and this pizza can definitely get in the ring with the best spots in NY…highly recommend!

So, we’re offering up delicious food, satisfying servings, and a fabulous rewards program. What’s not to love? Don’t slave over your stove tonight! Instead, bring home an authentic, New York-style pizza that your friends and family will love.