WE HAVE KNOWLEDGE

The Answer to Your Authentic Italian Pizza Near Me Search

When you’re searching online for authentic Italian pizza near me, you’re not just looking for any slice. In fact, you’re looking for that perfect blend of tradition, flavor, and craftsmanship. At Tony’s Pizza, we’ve made it our mission to serve just that. We are a family-owned pizzeria rooted in Italian heritage and New York tradition. Therefore, trust that we bring real-deal Italian flavor to every pie we make.

Come try our New York-style pizza made the authentic Italian way for yourself. You’ll only find that pizza goodness at Tony’s Pizza.

A Slice of History: From Naples to New York

Before we opened our doors in NC, pizza had already taken a long journey from Naples, Italy to NYC. The original pizza was a humble street food in Naples. It was a simple flatbread topped with tomatoes, mozzarella, and basil. As Italian immigrants brought their culinary traditions to America in the early 1900s, pizza followed.

In New York, this classic Italian dish evolved. It became larger, thinner, and crispier—perfect for folding and grabbing on the go. The high-heat ovens and fresh ingredients remained, but the pies got bigger and bolder. That’s the style we fell in love with, and that’s what we’ve brought to the Carolinas. It’s a New York-style pizza with authentic Italian soul.

What Makes a Pizza Truly Italian?

Not all pizza is created equal. Authentic Italian pizza is all about simplicity and balance. It involves these key features:

• Thin and airy crust
• Bright and tomato-forward sauce
• Fresh cheese
• Toppings used sparingly, but intentionally.

At Tony’s, we stay true to those principles. Our dough is made fresh daily. Plus, our sauce is based on time-honored family recipes. Finally, our toppings are chosen for quality—not quantity. You can taste the difference tradition makes in every bite.

The Tony’s Pizza Difference

We’re not just another pizza shop. In fact, we’re a family with deep roots in Calabria, Italy, where good food is a way of life. Our recipes have been passed down through generations. Then, we’ve built our business on those values: quality ingredients, honest cooking, and welcoming service.

While we specialize in NY-style pizza, our foundation is 100% Italian. That means we make every bite of our pizza with care. This includes everything from our hand-tossed crust to our savory sauce and gooey mozzarella. Whether you’re dining in or grabbing a slice to go, you’ll taste the Tony’s Pizza difference.

Menu Highlights That Scream “Authentic”

When it comes to flavor, our menu delivers. Here are a few of our must-try picks:

• Authentic NY-Style Pizza: We load our hand-tossed, thin-crust pies with care and tradition. Try our Pizza Bianco—a white pizza with ricotta, mozzarella, and garlic. Or, devour The Greenhouse, piled high with fresh veggies and full of bold, Italian flavor.
• Italian Comfort Foods: From cheesy strombolis to savory calzones, pasta dishes, and house-made cannoli, we offer more than just pizza.
• Options for Everyone: We proudly offer vegetarian choices and gluten-free crusts. Therefore, everyone will enjoy authentic pizza, their way. While we do our best to avoid cross-contamination, please note that our kitchen does handle gluten. So, unfortunately, we cannot guarantee a completely gluten-free environment.

Locations for Authentic Italian Pizza Near You

With locations in Charlotte, Mooresville, Hickory, and surrounding areas, it’s easy to find authentic Italian pizza near you. Whether you’re dining in with family, ordering takeout for a busy weeknight, or craving a delivery night in, we’ve got you covered.

Plus, our sister restaurant Mario’s Pizza has 9 locations in the Piedmont Triad of NC.

FAQ on Authentic Italian Pizza Near Me

Got questions about authentic Italian pizza near you? We’ve got answers! If you’re curious or ready to taste the real deal, come visit us. We can’t wait to serve you.

1. What Makes Tony’s Pizza Authentic Italian?

We use time-honored Italian recipes, fresh ingredients, and traditional techniques straight from our family’s roots in Calabria.

2. What is the Difference Between American Pizza and Authentic Italian Pizza?

Authentic Italian pizza features a thin, crisp crust, minimal yet high-quality toppings, and is cooked quickly at high heat—focusing on balance and freshness. American pizza often has a thicker crust, more cheese, and heavier toppings. We strike the perfect balance by offering New York-style pizza with authentic Italian flavor.

3. Do you Offer Vegetarian or Gluten-Free Options?

Yes! We have gluten-free crusts and a variety of vegetarian pizza options to suit your preferences. Please know that our kitchen does have gluten but we do our best to avoid cross contamination.

4. Where is the Nearest Tony’s Pizza Location?

Here are all six of our locations:

• Mooresville: 688 Bluefield Rd, Mooresville
• Galleria: 1605 Galleria Blvd, Charlotte
• Harris: 1530 Overland Park Ln, Charlotte
• Ballantyne: 14027 Conlan Cir, Charlotte
• Hickory: 1832 Catawba Valley Blvd SE, Hickory
• Huntersville: 9548 Mt Holly-Huntersville Rd, Huntersville

5. Can I Order Tony’s Pizza for Delivery?

Absolutely. You can order online on our website for delivery or takeout.

Come Taste the Real Deal

Next time you’re searching for authentic Italian pizza near me, skip the chains and come see us at Tony’s Pizza. We’re proud to serve slices that honor our Italian roots while embracing the New York style we love. From our family to yours, we are here to offer you a meal you won’t forget.

Stop by today or order online — we’ll have your favorite pie hot and ready.

Head over to our Facebook and Instagram for tons of delicious content!