Some people take pizza very seriously. To prove their skill, some chefs enter a world pizza championship to win a prestigious award. Most of us, however, are just looking for a great-tasting, authentic pizza pie. When looking for the best pizza in Lake Norman, visit Tony’s Pizza. We’re located at 688 Bluefield Rd Mooresville, NC 28117. Or, order by phone: 704-658-1926.

Characteristics Of The Best Pizza In Lake Norman

While most diners aren’t as discriminating as the world championship judges, we can use their guidelines for finding great pizza. Creating delicious pizza depends on each component blending together for the perfect pie:

1. Crust

Great pizza crust begins with a few simple ingredients. However, kneading, proofing, hand tossing, and baking techniques can have a profound effect on your results. Do everything correctly, and you’ll have a crispy and soft crust. Make one mistake along the way and you could end up with a dense, dried-out crust.

The founders of Tony’s Pizza, brothers Vinny, Tony, and Mario, began perfecting their pizza baking skills at an early age. As members of a large Italian family, the brothers learned the secrets to creating the perfect crust. Today, our restaurants use these same techniques to make delicious NY style pizza.

2. Sauce

The perfect pizza sauce requires the correct balance of fresh ingredients for a deep, robust flavor. It must complement the cheese and toppings without overpowering them. Additionally, the sauce must be thin enough to spread without being too watery (no soggy crusts!).

Here at Tony’s Pizza, we began with traditional recipes our family carried to America from Calabria, Italy. We’ve adjusted the spices to create a flavor unique to our restaurant. It’s the perfect balance of sweetness and acidity you’ve come to expect in a great pizza sauce.

3. Toppings

Using the correct balance of cheese and other toppings to sauce is trickier than you think. For example, adding too many toppings can interfere with baking resulting in a soggy crust. Yet, putting on too few will leave your customers wanting more. However, our chefs know exactly the precise amount for the perfect pizza.

Comparatively, some of our competitors have limited choices of toppings, but we offer a multitude:

  • Pepperoni
  • Sausage
  • Mushrooms
  • Black olives
  • Pineapple
  • Bell peppers
  • Anchovies
  • Artichoke hearts
  • Onions
  • Banana peppers
  • Bacon
  • Basil
  • Beef
  • Beef roni
  • Broccoli
  • Canadian bacon
  • Chorizo
  • Crispy chicken
  • Feta
  • Tomatoes
  • Grilled chicken
  • Green olives
  • Ham
  • Jalapenos
  • Kalamata olives
  • Meatballs
  • Roasted red peppers
  • Salami
  • Steak
  • Sliced sausage
  • Spinach
  • Sun dried tomatoes

And if you can’t decide, you can choose one of our specialty pizzas:

  • 5 Boroughs – meat lovers
  • Greenhouse – vegetable lovers
  • The Worx – a little bit of everything
  • Bianco Pizza – white pizza
  • Spicy Buffalo Chicken – chicken with a savory kick

4. Baking

Improper baking can ruin your pizza. Typically, you need a very hot oven to cook the pizza fast for a soft, chewy crust. Moreover, the longer you leave a pizza in an oven, the more likely you’ll have a dried-out crust. Plus, you run the risk of burning the cheese or other toppings.

Our chefs understand the delicate balance of temperature and timing. Additionally, we use specialty ovens to ensure even baking. Thus, every pizza we make is tantalizingly delicious.

Other Italian Cuisine At Tony’s Pizza

In addition to making the best pizza in Lake Norman, we also create authentic Italian dishes. Using traditional recipes handed down through generations, we create many of your favorites:

  • Lasagna
  • Chicken parmigiana
  • Eggplant parmigiana
  • Spaghetti
  • Baked Ziti
  • Ravioli

We also serve delectable sub sandwiches:

  • Steak
  • Grilled chicken
  • Chick-o-filly
  • Sausage parmigiana
  • Eggplant parmigiana
  • Chicken parmigiana
  • Meatball parmigiana
  • Sausage, peppers, and onions
  • Italian
  • Turkey
  • Vegetable

Plus, our menu also includes several salads, desserts, calzones, strombolis, and over a dozen appetizers. Moreover, for our younger diners, we have a kids’ menu with items priced at $5 or less.

Finally, we also offer some of your favorite Italian dishes in large party size trays. Whether you’re having a few extra friends over or planning a larger event, we can help make your celebration memorable.

FAQs About Tony’s Pizza

Ready to order some delicious pizza but have some hesitation? Below we answer a few more questions. If you have others, please call your nearest Tony’s Pizza.

Where Can I Find Tony’s Pizza?

You’ll find Tony’s Pizza at the following locations:

  • 688 Bluefield Road, Mooresville
  • 9548 Mt. Holly-Huntersville Road, Huntersville
  • 1832 Catawba Valley Boulevard SE, Hickory
  • 1530 Overland Park Lane, Charlotte
  • 1605 Galleria Boulevard, Charlotte
  • 14027 Conlan Circle, Charlotte

Do You Have A Loyalty Program?

We love to reward our customers for their continued support. That’s why we offer a great loyalty program with lots of perks. You can get free food, special offers, and cashback for doing what you love, eating delicious pizza.

Plus, we make it super easy to join. Simply download the app or let your server know the next time you order. We’ll even give you a free slice of pizza just for joining. Moreover, we’ll send you a special treat on your birthday.

What Else Makes Tony’s Special?

All of our restaurants also have online ordering, home delivery options, friendly staff, and dining-in space. While we could talk all day about our good qualities, we think our customers tell it best:

NY style pizza, large slices, they also have a 24″ pizza that is crazy. Always try to grab one while in Mooresville. – Michael M.

Huge pizza slices and great lunch specials. Good place for a casual bite and the workers were friendly. Happy to have stumbled on this place while visiting. – Ari A.

Are you hungry? Delicious pizza is waiting for you! When searching for the best pizza in Lake Norman, visit Tony’s Pizza.

Close on the tails of burgers, pizza is one of the second most popular fast foods in America. With a crispy crust, tangy sauce, and melty cheese, the flavorful favorite is tough to resist. Although, with so many pizzerias to choose from, how do you pick the best pizza Huntersville offers?

Must-Haves For A Great Pizza Place

There may be plentiful pizzerias in your town. However, not all have the best pizza Huntersville offers. Furthermore, the style of pizza is as important as the toppings. Whether you’re craving a big slice of  NY-style pizza or a deep dip into Chicago style, popular Italian restaurants have similar must-haves:

1. Fantastic Customer Reviews

First, search for reviews from customers.  At Tony’s Pizza, our loyal fan base loves to tell others about our pizza:

“Definitely service with a smile, Employees and food were outstanding. Pizza and wings were the best I’ve had in a good while. Definitely going to be coming back when I get the chance.” – Tony Church 

“Best Pizza in Huntersville. The Decor is tight also all NYC stuff! Been there, 300 times at least! Will be back! It changed owner’s, while I was still in NC! Pizza didn’t change! Yum.”– Michael Hartman

2. Multiple Menu Options

Of course, our specialty is delicious NY-Style pizza. Likewise, we offer many other delicious Italian dishes, appetizers, salads and desserts including: subs, calzones, stromboli, and parmigiana, meatballs, wings, cannoli, cheesecake and limoncello mascarpone cake.

3. Fabulous Food at Affordable Prices

Mostly, excellent Italian fare begins with traditional recipes from the old country. Tony’s Pizza traces their roots to Calabria, Italy.

Similarly, we also understand the importance of value and taking your family out to eat. Thus, we offer a kid’s menu with options for $5 and under along with daily specials for adults.

4. Ordering Online

Let’s face it, we all tend to lead busy lives. Ordering online is convenient. Therefore, Tony’s offers online ordering at all our locations. Choose to pick up your meal or have it delivered to your door. Whichever you choose, you’ll save time and get some great tasting pizza!

6 Qualities for the Best Tasting Pizza

While these pizzeria must-haves are important, let’s dig deeper into the best pizza Huntersville offers. After all, what really makes one restaurant’s pizza better than another? Below, here’s what we think makes the best tasting pizza.

1. Freshest Ingredients

Notably, fresh and preserved ingredients taste differently. When processed, these ingredients contain sodium, sugar, and preservatives to increase food’s shelf life. Unfortunately, these additives mar the true flavor. At Tony’s, we use the freshest ingredients possible.

2. Perfect Pizza Crust

Soggy, tasteless crust ruins any good pizza even if the toppings are superior. Whether you like thick or thin, best pizzas begin with well-crafted crust. Three characteristics that make the perfect crust are:

  • Texture
  • Thickness
  • Flavor

Hand tossing it a bit doesn’t hurt either. Another art we’ve perfected at Tony’s Pizza!

3. Savory Sauce

Once you perfect the base of your pizza, sauce is the next critical element. Perfectly seasoned fresh tomatoes enhance the overall flavor of the pie.

4. Tasty Toppings

True pizza lovers hotly debate which pizza toppings are best. Whichever combination you prefer, top pizza places offer plenty of options. At Tony’s Pizza, we have over twenty toppings to customize the perfect pizza.

5. Perfectly Cooked

Another hotly debated topic: wood-fired or gas oven? Each method may impart a slightly different taste. Although, seasoned chefs pay attention to oven temperature and cooking time as well.

6. Delicious

In the end, when you combine these qualities, you get a pizza that tastes delicious!

Best Pizza Huntersville – FAQs

Below, we’ve answered a few of our most commonly asked questions.

Do You Have Gluten-Free Pizza?

Absolutely! Choose from our rice-based or cauliflower crusts. Similarly, we have many gluten-free toppings. When you place your order, ask your server about safe options.

Do You Offer Special Deals?

Indeed, we do! Locate our daily specials on the menu section of our website. Better yet, join our loyalty program. Simply download the app from our website. Or, the next time you place an order, let a team member know you want to join.

Earn 1 point for every $2 you spend. Then, enjoy rewards for doing what you love – eating pizza! Get free food, $5 certificates, and special offers.

Where Can I Find Tony’s Pizza?

In Huntersville, you’ll find us at:

  • 9548 Mt. Holly-Huntersville RD

If in Mooresville, you’ll find Tony’s Pizza at:

  • 688 Bluefield Rd

We also have a location in Hickory:

  • 1832 Catawba Valley Blvd SE

If you’re in Charlotte we’re located on:

  • 1530 Overland Park Ln
  • 1605 Galleria Blvd
  • 14027 Conlan Circle

We look forward to proving that we have some of the best pizza Huntersville offers!