GIVE THE
Gift of Flavor!
Gift cards are available in any amount in any restaurant or on our app
Prices shown reflect a discounted CASH PAYMENT option. If payment is made via CARD, a 3% processing fee will be added at time of checkout.
View menu and more
In the Triad area? Visit our sister restaurant, Mario's Pizza!
and we love to share!
When you crave an Italian dessert, an Italian bakery often comes to mind. Yet, Tony’s Pizza, an Italian restaurant, has an exciting selection of authentic desserts made with traditional methods. Thus, consider stopping by to give our yummy desserts a taste test!
Italy is celebrated for its culinary heritage, featuring a variety of exquisite dishes. Among these, cheese plays a prominent role. Different regions in Italy boast their own unique cheese specialties. While we may not know when cheesemaking began, the Romans undeniably enhanced the art.
Why, then, bring up cheese? Notably, it’s a critical ingredient in numerous Italian desserts. Cheese adds unique textures and flavors to sweets, enriching them further. Moreover, its creamy goodness and gentle sweetness blend well with other components.
Luckily, you don’t have to seek out an Italian bakery to enjoy your favorite Italian sweets. At Tony’s Pizza, a range of freshly crafted desserts awaits:
Cannoli stands out as one of the most iconic Italian desserts. Originating from Sicily, this delicacy features a crispy shell filled with a luscious cream — a perfect fusion of flavors and textures.
The crunchiness starts with deep-fried dough that creates a wonderfully crispy shell. Marsala wine is a key ingredient that ensures its signature crispness and imparts a delightful taste.
Typically, the filling includes ricotta cheese and is lightly sweetened with powdered sugar. Sometimes, bakers mix in chocolate chips or candied fruits for added interest. To keep the shells crunchy, we fill them fresh upon order.
Another beloved dessert is tiramisu.
This treat features ladyfingers soaked in rich espresso coffee. Ladyfingers, delicate meringue cookies, possess a crunchy texture. Soaking them in coffee moistens and enhances their flavor.
Layers of these coffee-infused cookies alternately combine with a creamy mascarpone mixture made of mascarpone cheese, eggs, and sugar. This fluffy blend is whipped until smooth. To finish, a light dusting of cocoa powder crowns the dessert.
While cheesecake originated with the Greeks, the Italian version incorporates eggs and a pastry crust. As the Roman Empire expanded, this dessert found fans in various cultures, especially in England. It’s natural that early settlers brought their adaptations to America.
The traditional Italian cheesecake often uses ricotta and mascarpone, whereas American versions frequently relied on cottage cheese. The introduction of cream cheese in the 1920s transformed American cheesecake into a creamier, richer delight. Now, this tends to be the version most Americans favor. We serve NY-style cheesecake at Tony’s Pizza.
This cake combines a fluffy sponge texture, zesty lemon flavor, and the creamy richness of mascarpone. The base ingredient is Limoncello, a sweet Italian liqueur made by infusing lemon peels in grain alcohol. Sorrento lemons, known for their oil content, enhance the cake’s flavor.
The batter receives a boost of lemoniness (we don’t really know if that’s a word but declare it is now!) from this liqueur. After baking, we cover the limoncello-infused cake with a mascarpone icing mixed with lemon curd. The mascarpone contributes a smooth creaminess, while the lemon curd adds an extra zest. This results in a refreshing cake layered with decadently rich icing.
At Tony’s Pizza, we whip up freshly made desserts much like an Italian bakery. You’ll taste the quality in each bite. If you’re not yet familiar with our establishment, here are some common inquiries.
Tony’s boasts a diverse menu that caters to a wide audience. Along with our scrumptious desserts, we serve authentic New York-style pizza. With 32 toppings to choose from, you can create a custom pizza to suit your palate. Plus, we offer a variety of specialty pies, perfect for meat lovers or those who prefer vegetables.
You might also consider sampling one of our Italian entrees:
We also offer an array of salads, appetizers, subs, calzones, and strombolis. Moreover, our Italian bakery desserts and authentic Italian dishes are perfect for an Italian-themed party!
While Tony’s Pizza may seem unconventional for an Italian bakery, it’s important to note that our owners hail from a large Italian family in Brooklyn. They mastered the craft of creating delightful pastries early on. Today, we proudly carry on these family recipes, allowing us to serve genuine Italian dishes.
For busy diners, accessible locations are crucial. We strategically place our restaurants on important streets throughout the Charlotte and Hickory areas:
Absolutely! We provide party trays loaded with various Italian favorites:
Just give your nearest Tony’s Pizza a call a few days in advance to place your order.
Every dessert at Tony’s is crafted with care, following traditional methods and using only the freshest ingredients. Stop by Tony’s Pizza today for an unforgettable taste of Italy! In the interim, be sure to follow us on Facebook for the latest tasty news!