WE HAVE KNOWLEDGE

Discover the Origins of the Best Slice of NY Pizza

Manhattan is known for many classic foods. Cheesecake, the pastrami sandwich, and Waldorf Salad are just a few. Yet, the true star is the iconic slice of NY pizza. New York City also gave birth to “on-the-go pizza” eating, making it easy to grab a slice anywhere. When you crave an authentic slice of NY pizza, Tony’s Pizza stands out as a top choice.

Why Choose a Slice Over a Whole Pie?

Pizza is a favorite dish across America. However, many people do not have time to sit and enjoy a whole pie. The unique crust of a slice of NY pizza sets it apart. You can easily fold your slice, making it perfect for eating on the move. Here are some key benefits:

• Grab-and-go convenience for busy days
• Quick service with little waiting
• Reheated slices stay crispy and delicious
• Add any toppings you like for a personal touch

How Pizza by the Slice Became Popular

Pizza first appeared in Italy during the 1700s and was baked in wood-fired ovens. When Italian immigrants arrived in America, they used coal because it was more common. Coal-fired ovens produced a crispier, drier crust, which became the hallmark of NY style pizza. Eating pizza fresh from these ovens was essential, as the crust could turn tough when cold. This made selling slices difficult until gas ovens arrived.

Frank Mastro, an Italian immigrant, invented a way to use gas instead of coal. Gas ovens baked pizza more evenly at a steady temperature. The result was a drier crust that stayed tasty even after reheating. Pizzerias could now sell pizza by the slice and still deliver great flavor.

Comparing NY Style and Neapolitan Pizza

Neapolitan and NY style pizzas differ in more ways than just the crust. The switch from wood to gas ovens changed many things. For example, New York pizzerias used canned tomatoes. Unlike fresh tomatoes, canned ones have more acidity. To balance this, chefs added more seasoning to the sauce.

Another big difference is the cheese. Neapolitan pizza uses fresh mozzarella, which is high in water. A slice of NY style pizza uses low-moisture cheese. This keeps the crust from getting soggy during longer baking times. Low-moisture cheese melts perfectly, creating a classic NY slice.

Tony’s Pizza: Bringing Brooklyn Flavor to North Carolina

Tony’s Pizza stays true to the traditions of old-school pizzerias. Our owners, three Italian brothers from Brooklyn, moved to North Carolina in the 1980s with a dream. They wanted to bring a true slice of NY pizza to their new home. Today, you can find our restaurants at these locations in Charlotte and Hickory:

• 1605 Galleria Blvd, Charlotte
• 1530 Overland Park Ln, Charlotte
• 14027 Conlan Circle, Charlotte
• 688 Bluefield Rd, Mooresville
• 1832 Catawba Valley Blvd SE, Hickory
• 9548 Mt Holly-Huntersville Rd, Huntersville

At every Tony’s Pizza, our team hand-tosses dough and uses fresh ingredients. Each pizza reflects the legacy of the first Italian-American pizzerias. You can choose from 34 toppings to make your slice of NY pizza unique. If you cannot decide, try one of our specialty pizzas:

• Margherita
• 5 Boroughs
• Greenhouse
• The Worx
• Pizza Bianco
• Spicy Buffalo chicken
• Cauliflower or rice-based crusts

We serve pizza by the slice or as a whole pie in five sizes, from personal to party. Each slice is large, so you will not leave hungry.

What Our Customers Say About the Best Slice of NY Pizza

Ultimately, it’s our commitment to quality that makes us a local favorite. Here are a few recent comments from some of our customers:

“Definitely the best pizza in Mooresville. No close comparison if you like NY style pizza”. – Lisa P.

“The ONLY authentic NY pizza within 750 miles. Everyone else claims to have “NY style pizza” but it’s not. Not even close.” – Joe T.

“Love Tony’s Pizza in Mooresville. I’m from NYC, and Tony’s can compete with the best up there. Fugetaboutit!!!” –  Thomas W.

What You’ll Find on Tony’s Menu

Tony’s Pizza offers more than just pizza. Our menu features a wide range of Italian dishes:

• Appetizers: wings, garlic knots, toasted ravioli and more
• Salads: enjoy a side or a full meal
• Hot and cold subs in 11 options
• Strombolis and calzones
• Lasagna, baked ziti, spaghetti and other authentic Italian classics
• Eggplant and chicken parmigiana
• Desserts: tiramisu, NY cheesecake, limoncello mascarpone cake, cannoli

Tony’s Loyalty Program and Specials

Tony’s values our loyal customers. Join our rewards program by downloading the app or asking your server. Every purchase earns points. You can combine rewards with daily or lunch specials to save even more on your favorite slice of NY pizza. Join our loyalty club with an iPhone or Android today!

Catering Services at Tony’s Pizza

Tony’s Pizza makes events special with catering options. Our 24-inch pies and party trays are perfect for any gathering. Choose from a variety of Italian classics:

• Greek or garden salad
• Garlic knots
• Spaghetti with marinara or meatballs
• Lasagna or baked ziti
• Ravioli
• Chicken or eggplant parmigiana
• Cannoli

Please note, we do not deliver or set up catering orders. Call ahead so your food is ready for pickup.

Frequently Asked Questions

Have some questions about finding the best slice of NY pizza? Luckily, we have some answers!

What else is on Tony’s menu besides pizza?

You’ll find appetizers, salads, subs, pastas, parmigiana dishes, and classic Italian desserts.

Can I join a loyalty program?

Yes! Sign up through the app or with your server to start earning rewards.

Does Tony’s cater events?

Yes, Tony’s offers large pizzas and party trays for events. Call ahead to place your catering order.

Who serves authentic NY style pizza?

When you want a slice of NY pizza in North Carolina, visit Tony’s Pizza. We bring a taste of Brooklyn to your neighborhood.